Confession time. It may not be a
surprise from reading my blog, but I’ll be clear: I’m a leftist. A
liberal. An adherent of Classical Liberalism, who believes that the socialist welfare state, for all
its flaws, is the best way to ensure the kind of just and equitable society people
would want to live in.
So now that that’s out of the way, I have one question for all of you: What the
hell are you all doing?
Let’s do a thought experiment. Imagine
you are a member of ISIS. As Mr. ISIS, you’ve got a fairly unambiguous goal: to
destroy the entire corrupt and degenerate West in an apocalyptic battle. But
right now, you’ve got two main problems. The first, is that people in your own
country keep trying to live ordinary, peaceful lives where they don’t get
immolated in a holy war (boo!). The second, the evil west doesn’t appear to be
that interested in you, as they’re too busy having fun, drinking coke, watching
TV, and living normal lives (hiss!). But you’re smart, and relatively reasonable.
How do you get the West to attack you and your citizens, solving your two
problems?
I’m going to stop here, because it’s
pretty obvious what you do, and we’ve seen how easy it has been to force a
reaction from America. The more the average citizen can no longer live in
peace, the more likely it is for them to have no choice but to join your holy
war. And any clumsy move by the opposing side helps them.
So what do you do if you’re America? If
you respond in the obvious way, you’re playing right into Mr. ISIS’s hands. He’s
hoping for that reaction, and counting on it. But at the same time, not reacting isn’t exactly an option, as
our Mr. ISIS will have to keep trying, ramping up his aggression until he gets
the outcome he wants. It’s a no-lose situation for him.
As is quickly becoming a theme in this
blog, I don’t have the answers to this one either. Ideally, the response would
be some sort of third, paradigm breaking thing, that delegitimizes Mr. ISIS
without playing into his hands.
If you haven’t figured out where I’m
going with this yet, stop wondering. It’s about Donald Trump again. Donald
Trump may be loathsome and rude, but he is not stupid. He is very good at
placing himself in these “no-lose” situations, just like our friend Mr. ISIS. So
let’s take it as a given that Trump is thinking at least one step ahead,
anticipating the likely responses to anything he does.
In that case, what is meant to happen with
this immigration ban? The same thing that happens every time he tries to push
people’s buttons: he wants people to react (I talk more this as a negotiation
tactic in a previous post).
But the point is, the left rising up en masse represents a victory condition
for him. This is only the first few weeks, he’s trying to solidify his base. His
power comes from the millions of people who see themselves as a persecuted
minority in their own country, and mass demonstrations are not helping the
matter.
I allude to this in the conclusion of
my Fascism post, but I’ll be explicitly clear: a massive demonstration of
people who are not them, spouting slogans and behaving in the manner of the
least intelligent member of the crowd is the opposite of helping. All it does is solidify in their minds that
Trump is their guy, gotta stick with him, he’s really giving it to those guys
who aren’t us and gosh do we appreciate it.
A protest is the kind of move that
Trump is predicting and counting on. And while I’m not going to speculate on
the end goal in this post, I would imagine it looks a lot like Mr. ISIS's.
And Trump will use, and has used, the same strategy again and again. And he will continue to do so for as long as it works. I’ll make a not-so-bold prediction: look for him to repeat this same thing next week, with an executive order that targets LGBT folks, followed by frothing outrage. (Note: I am writing this on Monday, January 23, 2017)
And Trump will use, and has used, the same strategy again and again. And he will continue to do so for as long as it works. I’ll make a not-so-bold prediction: look for him to repeat this same thing next week, with an executive order that targets LGBT folks, followed by frothing outrage. (Note: I am writing this on Monday, January 23, 2017)
This is not a secret, it is their stated strategy. Bannon and Trump are many things, but they are not stupid. They know that the media will
react that way. They are counting on it.
And as long as he can keep identifying safe
outgroup
punching bags, he’s going to keep doing it. The protests are part of the
plan.
I don’t know how to stop it, or how to
break the cycle, but we have to think more. We’ve got to start playing multiple
moves ahead. Because right now, the left is doing nothing but reacting, and if
we keep doing that, we’re going to lose everything that matters.
(2/4/17 EDIT: So that executive order I was predicting seems to be on hold, though I would still be surprised if there wasn't some new outrage by the end of the next week. But I wanted to make clear that the "Mr. ISIS" bit was a rhetorical device, and a gross oversimplification of the historical causes of unrest and animosity between the middle east and the west. While there were certainly recent causes, these conflicts have been fermenting for over a hundred years (if not earlier). Overturning Sykes-Picot is a stated objective of ISIS/ISIL. I may revisit this in a future post, as events warrant.)
(2/4/17 EDIT: So that executive order I was predicting seems to be on hold, though I would still be surprised if there wasn't some new outrage by the end of the next week. But I wanted to make clear that the "Mr. ISIS" bit was a rhetorical device, and a gross oversimplification of the historical causes of unrest and animosity between the middle east and the west. While there were certainly recent causes, these conflicts have been fermenting for over a hundred years (if not earlier). Overturning Sykes-Picot is a stated objective of ISIS/ISIL. I may revisit this in a future post, as events warrant.)
شركة جلي الرخام في دبي
ReplyDeleteشركة مكافحة حشرات دبي
شركة تنظيف في دبي
شركة تعقيم دبي
شركة تسليك مجارى في دبي
شركة كشف تسربات المياه في دبي
شركة تركيب جبس بورد في دبي
شركة عزل اسطح فى دبي
شركة تركيب باركيه بدبي
تصليح مكيفات دبي